🎉 Egg bundles are back! Get our pastured, corn & soy free honest yolks eggs at a discount. BUY EGGS.

Is your raw cheese actually raw? Or has it been greenwashed?

written by

Marie Reedell

posted on

July 10, 2024

cheeses.jpg

I know you get frustrated with misleading labels. Me, too! Sadly, I just found out about a new one to watch out for...

Imagine that you're shopping in a cheese department. You spot some raw cheese. Hooray! 

So, you buy the cheese. But then, you read the fine print on the back of the label. For example, on Organic Valley's raw cheeses, it says "Heated to 158F for 15 seconds". Ugh!!!

What's up with this? Another greenwashed label? Shouldn't raw cheese not be heated at all? Doesn't heating to 158F negate the purpose of purchasing raw?

Let's dive a little deeper.

How heating milk past 110F alters digestibility and nutrition

I mean, in terms of health, raw cheese is the best. Milk in its raw state has more nutritional value compared to pasteurized milk. 

When milk isn't heated past 110F, all the natural microbiology, vitamins, and minerals stay intact. And that means max digestibility and nutrition for you. This makes logical sense, since milk straight from a cow is around 102F.

When milk is heated above 110F, it changes. Here's a chart breaking it down:

The amount of damage done is directly related to the amount of processing. The higher the pasteurization temp and time, the more the naturally healthy parts of the milk are damaged. In addition, when milk is homogenized, it breaks down nutrients and fats.

Why milk needs to be heated to make cheese

You can't make cheese without a little heat. The cultures simply wouldn't grow.

Mesophilic cultures work at temps ranging from 62–102F. The most common temp for this type of culture is around  90F. They are used to make many types of cheese, including cheddar, gouda, chèvre, muenster, and camembert.

Thermophilic cultures work at temps ranging from 104–112F. They are used to make cheeses like mozzarella, parmesan, provolone, swiss, and romano.

The legal regulations for raw cheese

Legally, as long as the milk isn't heated to the the legal pasteurization temp of 161F on "properly operated equipment", it's still considered "raw milk". And cheese made from that milk can be labeled as "raw cheese". 

Here are the legal pasteurization temps and times:

  • 145F for 30 minutes
  • 161F for 15 seconds
  • 191F for 1 second
  • 204F for 0.05 second
  • 212F for 0.01 second

So, if Organic Valley heats the milk to 158F for 15 seconds (just under the legal 161F for 15 seconds), they can label it as "raw cheese".

Or, if a cheesemaker heats the milk to to any temp or time, but they don't use "properly operated equipment" that's certified and records temps and times, guess what? Yup, it can be labeled as "raw cheese".

Both of the above examples are 100% legal and within the regulations. 

A few other legal requirements for raw cheese:

  • The cheese needs to be aged 60 days or more. 
  • Must contain less than 45% moisture.
  • Must contain more than 50% milkfat.

What doesn't need to be disclosed on raw cheese labels

The temp the milk was heated to does NOT need to be on a cheese label. 

The ingredients in the cheese need to be on the label (for example: milk, salt, cultures, rennet). But not necessarily the nitty gritty ingredients:

  • The type of enzymes (or rennet) used and the origin of those enzymes (animal, plant, or microbial) do NOT need to be listed. A label can simply say "enzymes" or "rennet".
  • The exact strains used in the culture does NOT need to be listed. A cheese label typically says "cultures".
  • Any additives in the culture or rennet do NOT need to be listed (things like propylene glycol, maltodextrin, dyes, etc)

Why mozzarella simply cannot be truly raw

I see folks out there selling "raw" mozzarella. Sure they might be starting out by culturing raw milk not heated above 110F. But a true raw mozzarella is simply not possible, and here's why. 

When you make mozzarella cheese, you culture milk with the specific mozzarella strains. Then, you separate the curds and whey. And finally, you need to stretch the curd.

In order to stretch the curd, you need to put the curd in very hot water. The minimum temp for this to happen is 165F. And that curd needs to be fully heated to that temp in order to stretch.

In short, raw mozzarella is NOT a thing.

Why Miller's raw cheeses are truly raw

When one of our A2/A2 cheeses says "raw", we mean it. The milk is only heated enough so the cheese cultures can thrive, and that's never past 110F.

Plus, we also give you the nitty gritty details in the product description for each cheese. That includes:

  • The type of rennet
  • The exact cultures
  • Any additives in any ingredient used in the cheesemaking process

At Miller's Bio Farm, we take our job of providing you with truly natural food seriously. We give you so much info on our site, so you can be a smart natural food shopper. And, if there's any info you can't find but would like to know, please reach out. We're happy to help!

-----

Resources

More from the blog

Does varying yolk color affect the flavor of honest eggs?

As you know, we don't add any color to our feed. This is why our pastured corn & soy free eggs are called "honest yolk eggs". "Color" includes unnatural stuff like dyes as well as natural stuff like marigold and paprika. Nearly all egg farmers nowadays do this... even the natural ones. Why? People demand consistent color yolks, thinking it means a certain quality. Little do most know, yolk color is superficial now. At Miller's, we know this for a fact. Curiosity made us to send our eggs for testing, and there was zero nutritional difference in our orange vs yellow yolk eggs. What mattered most was the farming practices and quality of the feed, and our eggs came out on top for most tests. We really love having varying yolk color. It's an indicator of what the birds are eating.  It tells our farmers how their pasture is doing. If the plants are too mature, not diverse enough, it's too wet or dry, or if chickens aren't eating the pasture, we'll see that with the yolk color! Now, we've had an array of responses since we removed the color from our feed. One baffling one is --- the light colored yolks don't taste as good as the dark colored yolks. Is this true? I mean, removing the color is only a superficial change. It shouldn't affect the flavor. Well, we needed to find out. So... we did a blind tasting on the farm a few weeks ago. Here's what that looked like: The results? The whole team agreed -- all eggs tasted the same! The biggest factor affecting egg flavor was the yolk to white ratio. The more yolk, the more flavor.  It's spring, and our hens are out on pasture 100% of the time. An egg develops for about 6 weeks inside a chicken, so it takes some time. But... you should start to see darker yolks now. Have you noticed a change in yolk color? Have you noticed a flavor change? Would you prefer consistent colored yolks or honest yolks? I'd love to hear from you. Comment below or contact us 😊 PS: The egg shortage is 100% over, and we have plenty of eggs now!! That means egg bundles are back!

See a volcano of pickles! The pluses and minuses of natural ferments.

A customer shared his farm food order with us on Instagram. Thanks for sharing, Nick! It included this amazing video of the volcano that can erupt from our fermented pickles: What's going on here? Why so many bubbles? Conventional pasteurized vinegar pickles (you know, the kind that are considered "normal") don't bubble at all. What you're seeing is the fermentation.  When fermented pickles are made, it's a very simple process. The following is mixed in a jar: Cucumbers, well water, celery seed, mustard seed, dill, garlic, Celtic sea salt, and whey. Then, the jar sits with a loose lid for 3-7 days, until it's done fermenting. The seeds and herbs are in there for flavor only. The cucumbers, water, salt, and whey are what make the magic happen. Note that there is no powdered culture added. Yes, whey is added and it has probiotics, but it simply helps jumpstart the ferment. Even without the whey, those pickles would ferment. It would just take a little longer. This is because raw veggies naturally have lactic acid bacteria (LAB) in them. When you mix them with water and salt, it creates the perfect environment for them to grow. Pretty cool, right? The living microbiology (the LAB) grow and multiply. They eat the naturally occurring sugars and starches in the cucumbers and produce CO2, a gas.  The fermentation carbonated the pickle brine! The fermentation made the volcano! It's also a sure sign that there's plenty of good probiotic stuff for your gut in that jar. The white stuff is yeast (most likely KAHM yeast).  Another thing to notice in the jar is how the liquid is whitish, not clear. There's nothing unsafe about it. Yes, you can eat it! It's a natural part of fermentation.  You see, KAHM yeast thrives in acidic environments. As that probiotic goodness ferments and creates CO2, it also creates lactic acid. The lactic acid not only gives pickles their distinct sour flavor but also makes the brine acidic.  KAHM yeast is naturally in the air. It will land on a ferment and think "Gee, this would be a great home." And then it grows. It typically makes a film on the top of a ferment, but it can also sink to the bottom. With volcanic pickles, it gets all mixed up in the brine and will eventually settle.  Fermented veggies are an acquired taste. Nick, who shared the volcanic pickles video, reported that: "The pickles are absolutely delicious. I love them!"  But... we sometimes get complaints about the flavor of the pickles and the white stuff. Is Nick's palate simply more accustomed to ferments? Were some jars of pickles actually off? It's really hard to say... especially when you're not there smelling and tasting it yourself. What I do know is that fermented veggies are an acquired taste. They're very different from the distinct pasteurized vinegar pickle flavor you likely grew up with.  Fermented pickles have umami to them (think about that "weird" flavor in miso or a very sharp aged cheese). They have a lot of tang. They can even taste metallic. Some may feel a burn on their tongue (that's the lactic acid by the way).  You may want to try making some at home (as I said before, it's pretty easy). That way, you can taste the flavor throughout the fermentation process and put it in the fridge when you think they're just right. Fermented veggies can last months in the fridge with proper maintenance. Here are a few tips to keep them in their best shape. Always store in the fridge. This will slow down the fermentation so they don't get overdone. If you leave them on the counter (especially pickles), they'll get quite sour and mushy pretty quickly. Never freeze ferments. They'll just get mushy. Make sure the veggies are always covered with brine. If the brine falls below the veggies, simply add more water and sea salt. So easy! If the veggies aren't covered, they can grow mold or dry out and become yucky.  If there's too much KAHM yeast, remove it. KAHM yeast is perfectly safe to eat. However, it can have an off-putting flavor, especially when there's too much. If it's on the top of the brine, simply scoop it off. If it's all mixed up in the brine, let the jar sit for a day or two so it settles. Once it sinks to the bottom of the jar, you can remove the pickles and clean brine (leaving the white stuff at the bottom), clean the jar, and then put the pickles and brine back in. Voila!  With this in mind, you might be wondering... Can ferments become unsafe? If a lacto-fermented veggie goes wrong, it will be pretty obvious. It may have a repulsive smell, flashy colors (like pink or black mold), or a foul flavor. While a normal ferment should have a sour, tangy smell, a bad ferment will smell putrid or rotten. This can be a little tricky, especially if you're new to ferments. The flavor can be wild! Often you simply need to trust your gut. Although getting used to ferments can take some time and know how, it's worth it. Why? They're just so darn good for your gut. They're packed with a range of lactic acid bacteria. Fermented veggies usually have bifidobacteria, too, which isn't prevalent in fermented dairy but is crucial for healthy digestion. When you have robust and healthy gut microbiology:  The bad stuff simply can't grow. You're less likely to get sick. Your digestion is better overall, meaning that you get max nutrition from the food you eat.Your gut can better produce essential nutrients like short-chain fatty acids and vitamins B1, B9, B12, and K.You can experience less inflammation.Your gut-brain connection is better. You may find yourself in a better mood, with less stress. There's probably so much more, but those are the top ones for me! Do you eat or make ferments? Why or why not? Have you tried the pickles? What's your experience? I'd love to hear from you! Comment below (no account required - start typing for the guest option to appear) or contact us. 

Why spring grass milk is the most healthy, creamy, yellow, and delicious.

Ahhhh, spring grass fed milk. It’s just the best milk of the entire year. You can see that it’s yellower and creamier. You can taste its full flavor and earthiness. In your gut, you just know that this milk is good for you. It’s simply the best. With modern testing, we can quantify that we’re not crazy for believing this or feeling this within our bodies. It’s scientifically true. Spring grass fed milk is the healthiest milk. Let’s explore.